Civic participation is both a human right and an enabler of collective intelligence, which in turns favours better governance. Therefore, it has both an intrinsic and an instrumental value. As of late 2025, UNDP examined the work of the Accelerator Labs network that involved innovative forms of civic participation over the period 2019-2025. This examination resulted in a publication, The Edge of Participation. This metaboard gives the reader access to the raw data for that publication: the documentation of the various experiences from the Labs.
SDG(s)
Sustainable Development Goal(s)
1No poverty
6Clean water and sanitation
7Affordable and clean energy
10Reduced innequalities
14Life below water
4Quality education
8Decent work and economic growth
15Life on land
5Gender equality
11Sustainable cities and communities
12Responsible consumption and production
Civic engagement as an enabler of collective intelligence
Civic engagement is the process through which people come together, as members of a community, to pursue shared goals. This process can take different forms. It may be geared towards influencing the actions of the state – such as when people organize to provide inputs into policy making. Or it may be more community-focused – for instance, when people tap into local knowledge and relations to generate new solutions to shared development challenges.
In all its different forms, civic engagement is a human right. Protecting people’s ability to meaningfully engage in public life – beyond the delegation of power to office holders – is essential to upholding human dignity and freedom. Civic engagement has, therefore, an intrinsic value. However, at the same time, it also has an instrumental value as an enabler of collective intelligence, which, in the right circumstances, leads to better collective decisions and unlocks benefits for human development.<
When people pool together insights, skills and ideas in a collaborative process, their contributions often become more than the sum of their individual efforts. This enhanced capacity – which we refer to as “collective intelligence” – can be very powerful and has always been central to humanity’s ability to solve problems quickly and at scale.
Civic engagement, by mobilizing members of society beyond the confines of public institutions and by building bridges between communities and public institutions, is a major driver of collective intelligence. By this term we mean the enhanced capacity that is created when people work together, often with the help of technology, to mobilize a wider range of information, ideas and insights. Especially when it is truly inclusive – when it creates space for people from all walks of life to contribute – collective intelligence can have a major impact in harnessing our world’s collective brainpower and unleashing human ingenuity.
Three emergent patterns
We find that the mapped experiences tend to gravitate around three primary areas of focus:
Enabling voice. Initiatives where R&D helps bring citizen perspectives into policymaking.?
Collaborative design. Initiatives where R&D brings state and non-state stakeholders together to find solutions to complex problems.
Spurring collective action. Initiatives where R&D taps into community resilience and unlocking self-organizing.
Consider a very simple model of collective outcomes as the result of a linear process that consists of first, acquiring information; second, making decisions based on that information; and third, taking action to execute those decisions. With another simplification, consider the citizenry’s collective intelligence and formalized governance processes as the two main forces that drive this process. The three patterns described above can be classified in terms of the phases of the process where collective intelligence has a role to play.
An emergent research agenda
Five years of bottom-up R&D on participation by the UNDP Accelerator Labs Network have resulted in many innovative approaches that are now tested, have shown significant promise, and are ready for scale. At the same time, it is important to stress that the search for effective participation pathways is a never-ending process. Many questions remain wide open, when it comes to the promotion of meaningful citizen participation in public decision-making processes.
Power asymmetries. Inequality, it has been said, is always in the room. How can fair participation processes be promoted, when different parts of society come into these processes with vastly different capacities to articulate their point of view and pursue their aspirations?
Complexity. Many issues that affect everyone, and on which every member of society should be able to weigh in, are also complex. How can public dialogue be structured to be rigorous (and reflective of policy trade-offs) while also, at the same time, accessible to laypeople?
Polarization. Polarization, including perceived polarization, can erode the very possibility of dialogue. How can, then, processes of inclusive decision-making be pursued in societies where people are not able to recognize other points of view as legitimate, especially in contexts of conflict and fragility?
Lack of vertical trust. Trust is notoriously difficult to build and easy to lose. How can institutions and office holders genuinely interested in dialogue be supported in gaining the necessary public confidence in contexts that are characterized by deeply entrenched distrust towards public authority?
Speed and scale. Enabling meaningful citizen participation is neither cheap nor easy – it requires in fact significant resources and, more importantly, time. How can social and technological innovation be leveraged to reconcile the need for speed and scale with the time and resource limitations of public institutions?
The central proposal of this document is that five years of bottom-up innovation on participation provide us with new tools for a direct attack at some of these questions. UNDP is committed to continue to pursue a bottom-up approach to R&D, in collaboration with a wide range of partners, to address these and other questions that are central to the promotion of civic engagement and the facilitation of collective intelligence.
Selected cases of how UNDP is helping citizens bring their own perspectives into policymaking. In collaboration with the Governance Team of the Bureau for Policy and Programme Support.
Selected cases of how UNDP is tapping into community resilience and unlocking self-organization. In collaboration with the Governance Team in the Bureau for Policy and Programme Support.
Selected cases of how UNDP is bringing stakeholders together to find shared solutions to complex problems. In collaboration with the Governance Team in the Bureau for Policy and Programme Support.